'Outer Banks' stars Madison Bailey and Carlacia Grant put their taste buds to the test in a blind tasting challenge featuring luxury vs. budget seafood, the perfect menu for two Pogues who spend plenty of time by the water–or is it? In this episode of Taste Off, the Kiara and Cleo actors sample expensive and affordable versions of coconut shrimp, white wine, smoked oysters, caviar, and cocktail sauce to see whether the pricier pick really tastes better. But while Carlacia, a known foodie, is versed in everything from the many types of caviar to fresh-shaved horseradish, Madison admits seafood isn't exactly her comfort zone, raising the stakes every time a new plate arrives.